21 Trendy Baby Shower Prize Ideas

When you’re hosting a baby shower, one party planning detail that can sneak up on you is game prizes. What prizes do you give at baby showers after all? Perhaps right now you’re in that moment of panic when you’re like “thank God I remembered, but now what do I do!?” Or maybe you’re a super buttoned up planner who is doing research well in advance of your event looking for the best baby shower prize ideas.

Whether you’re last minute or not, this post will give you 21 trendy baby shower game prize ideas – organized by price point. There’s something here for every budget!

As with anything, presentation is key. Even the smallest, lowest cost prizes can look WAY more expensive if packaged thoughtfully.

Without further ado, let’s dive in!

This post may contain affiliate links. We will receive a commission if you make a purchase through our affiliate link at no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure here.

Baby Shower Prize Ideas

$5 Baby Shower Prizes

1 \ Gift Card: Really, you cannot go wrong with a coffee gift card. Support local if possible. However, if you’re looking for something more far reaching (especially if you have a lot of out-of-town guests coming to the shower), then go for Starbucks.

2 \ Lip Balm: Rosebud lip salve is a baby shower prize that will be appreciated by just about everyone. And this one comes packaged in a darling tin. Save even more by buying in multiples, if you have more than one game to purchase a prize for!

3 \ Chocolate: What’s better than chocolate? Chocolate that gives back! This line of endangered species chocolate does good and looks good, making it a terrific inexpensive baby shower prize for games.

4 \ Facial Masks: Individually wrapped facial masks are a ubiquitous self-care item. Seems like just about everywhere you go, brands have their own version. While you can easily spend a lot on them at high end stores, there are tons of great options priced $5 and under. Give one or package a few together.

5 \ Notebooks: If you have three games, this set of notebooks can be broken in to three different prizes. I love that each one is a different design. Adorable designs, at that!

6 \ Small Batch Jam: Food baby shower game prizes are a safe bet on something just about everyone will enjoy. After all, we all need to eat! And who doesn’t love jam!? (Well, my kids don’t. But besides them. Who doesn’t love jam!?)

7 \ Reusable Shopping Bags: Small and compact, these self-enclosed shopping bags will do the trick when you’re not sure what else to give. Easily tucked in purses for errands, they’re the game prize that keeps on giving.

$10 Baby Shower Prizes

8 \ Nice Nail Polish: This “mommy collection” by Ella Mila is certainly on brand for the occasion. You could break apart the set and give one bottle per prize. If you want to sweeten the pot, add a nail file tied to the lid with a bow to give to the baby shower game winners who really “nailed it.” (couldn’t help myself. sorry!)

9 \ Jade Roller: Little luxuries like jade rollers will be a coveted by your guests. This mini roller comes in packaging as darling as the product itself!

10 \ Girl Power: If you’re hosting a baby shower for a girl, give these bath bombs in boxes featuring famous strong women of change. Perfect, right!?

11 \ Bangle Keychain: Playing “What’s In Your Purse”? If so, this is a super fun way to keep the prize on brand with the game.

12 \ Tea: If this tea tastes as good as the tin box it comes in looks, then you cannot go wrong with choosing this as a prize. While it comes in several different flavors, the color palette of this box seems to fit a baby shower best.

13 \ Cute Mug: Can one ever have enough cute mugs? If my kitchen cabinets are any indication, then the answer is a solid no!

14 \ Linen Spray: Another little luxury, linen spray is something most people don’t think to buy for themselves. Receiving it as a prize winnings would be a fun and appreciated surprise.

$20 Baby Shower Prizes

15 \ French Hand Soap: Hands down, French hand soap is a lovely option for a baby shower game prize. Prettily packaged, you’ll hardly have to add anything to make it feel giftable.

16 \ Body Scrub: MegaBabe shower scrub “from my shower to yours,” keeps the theme running strong through your baby shower.

17 \ Glass Tumbler: Insta famous, your guests will fight over these super-popular tumblers. They come in lots of colors, which you can choose to coordinate with your baby shower theme. Purchase the multi-packs to save a few dollars per tumbler, as a little hint!

18 \ Luxury Candle: Candles are another item most people can’t get enough of, especially when they are as pretty as this one! The floral printed lid could easily tie into a lot of different baby shower color palettes.

19 \ Kitchen Essentials: Anyone else geek-out over nice cleaning products!? A set of kitchen essentials would make an exceptional grand prize, like this one from Williams-Sonoma. It’s the highest priced item of all the baby shower prize ideas on this list, but it is almost guaranteed to be a hit.

20 \ Reed Diffuser: If candles are iffy for you, then a reed diffuser is an excellent alternative.

21 \ Tea Towel: Last but not least, a tea towel rolled up and tied with a ribbon would be a welcomed game prize. Try to choose a neutral color that can easily coordinate with most home decor.